Topic 2: Digital Identity

tumblr_m10x6dUz371rrfhh2o1_1280

Image Source: http://sattsat.tumblr.com/post/19445364906

Digital identity derives from the practices individuals have been developing online and it centres around two areas: presentation of the persona assumed and reputation. (Costa & Torres 2011:49) There is an idea that, among other dichotomies, users can assume multiple online identities; not just one.

Based on the notion that initiation of any online activity initiates a digital identity, it is plausible in that sense to believe that we can occupy many online personas dictated by the nature of the activity in which we are involved and the purpose of the medium in question. For example, LinkedIn’s purpose is for professional use, so my display picture reflects that, the tone of my profile is appropriate as is the content – it is a digital reflection of exactly how I would present myself in the work place; smart attire, polite mannerisms and work-related discourse. Whereas on Facebook, whose nature is much more relaxed, my pictures are comedic and my language is  colloquial, just like my personality around friends in everyday life.

Costa & Torres however, imply that perhaps it is better to maintain one online identity, as they argue that multiple online identities interfere with the credibility of our identity, causing a suspicion among users. From my experience, I disagree – I don’t think it inspires scepticism because different services have distinct purposes and people act accordingly just as they do offline as I illustrated in my examples above. However I do understand the concern that it is difficult to decipher who the ‘real’ person behind the profile is, but I think that comes down to mismanagement of online privacy. Using my own profiles as an example, I think they are consistent with each other even though my personas vary; my social media are of similar tones with each other as they are with my LinkedIn because I am conscious of the digital identity I leave behind in my digital footprint regardless of the online activity in question. My online identity is open, but it isn’t completely open because I am aware of the negative repercussions of over-sharing.

It is debated that a single online identity is impossible to attain, whereas Mark Zuckerberg suggests that it is in fact the exact direction of where the internet is headed towards in the future. “Zuckerberg believes we have one authentic identity and says it is becoming less and less true that people will maintain separate identities.” (Jarvis 2011) So perhaps the fear of reputational damage at the work-place for that photo tagged of you from last weekend will disappear as “we will soon operate under the doctrine of mutually assured humiliation” (Jarvis 2011) and our reputation offline will not be affected by our identity online because our various online personas will all eventually merge into one.

Micheal Zimmer opposes this notion as he explains that we present ourselves differently offline depending on the situation we are in, and that online it is no different, and I for one agree. I adjust my behaviour accordingly depending on the environment; I do not act 100% the same with my parents as I do with my friends nor in a meeting with my academic advisor, but that is not to say that I am not being myself or not being genuine  – I’m conducting myself appropriately given the setting. Zimmer concludes, “This is how we navigate the multiple and increasingly complex spheres of our lives. It is not that you pretend to be someone that you are not; rather, you turn the volume up on some aspects of your identity, and tone down others, all based on the particular context you find yourself.” (Zimmer 2010)

So if we have multiple personas offline, surely by presenting one, single persona online, that would be inauthentic, not the other way around.

 

REFERENCES

Costa, C. & Torres, R. (2011) ‘To be or not to be, the importance of Digital Identity in the networked society.’ Revista Educação, Formação & Tecnologias, n.o extra (Abril, 2011): (47-53).

Jarvis, J. (2011) ‘One identity or more?’, online, Available: http://buzzmachine.com/2011/03/08/one-identity-or-more/  [Accessed 28.02.2016].

Zimmer, M. (2010) ‘Facebook’s Zuckerberg: “Having two identities for yourself is an example of a lack of integrity”.’, online, Available: http://www.michaelzimmer.org/2010/05/14/facebooks-zuckerberg-having-two-identities-for-yourself-is-an-example-of-a-lack-of-integrity/ [Accessed 28.02.2016].

 

 

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Topic 2: Digital Identity”

  1. Hi Anna,
    Reading your post made me wanting to leave a comment for you as I think you wrote this post very nicely put together with mixing the theories with examples of yourself and it made me thinking.
    I think there are different views for how people can see the idea of having multiple online identities. In my point of view, by multiple identities I rather understand the concept of having different, even fictional names and profiles on the different social media platforms (as it allows you anonimity and it is harder to track you etc…). From you post, I get the idea that you prefer sharing always the real yourself but with always adapting to the current situation/environment, which is only about highlighting the appropriate sides of you without showing you are someone else. I totally agree with you, but I call it having one identity. It is the same you, same name probably, but adjusted appropriately to the different platforms such as being professional on LinkedIn and having more fun and relaxed conversastions on Facebook as you said.
    It is really interesting, how we can agree on something but calling the concept differently at the same time. Looking forward to your posts!
    Theo
    Ps: You should give me some nice linguist tips x

  2. Hi Anna-Clare,
    I agree completely with your second paragraph in which you discuss how you show different sides of your personality based on which social media platform you are using (I do the same).
    Do you think that Zuckerberg’s statement implies that soon people will only use one social media site to express all sides of their persona? If so which site do you think it would be?

    I completely agree with your concluding point that having only one online persona would be inauthentic as we do behave differently in different scenarios in the real world depending on who we are addressing. You mentioned that you Facebook account was similar to “how you’d act with friends” what real-life scenarios would you relate your other social media profiles to e.g. twitter or instagram ?

  3. Hi Anna-Clare, great post!

    You noted how Michael Zimmer has made the point that we act differently offline depending on the situation and that the online world is no different, and that you agree with this notion. I definitely agree with you to an extent, and I can recall situations where this is evident in my own life. For example, whenever I’ve been in a job interview situation, the ‘LinkedIn’ me comes out and I try to be as professional as possible. When I’m just with my housemates, family or friends, the ‘Twitter’ or ‘Facebook’ me comes out, and I am much more relaxed and personal.

    However, I am not fully convinced with Zimmer’s argument; there are distinct differences between offline and online multiple identities. I think the main difference is the fact that it is so much easier online, and in some ways this makes it more of a deceptive act. When I have a job interview, as much as I try to be professional, it’s often difficult for me to not let some of the real ‘personal’ me come out.

    Do you think that the difference between online and offline multiple identities is something to be considered?

  4. […] Anna-Clare’s blog post introduced me to the views of Zimmer and helped me to further synthesize my knowledge on the topic. This post allowed me to consider the fact that having multiple online identities is no different to how we act in real life; changing the way we act based on the situation. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s